Daimler blasts Chinese copycats
Carmaker in Smart FourTwo legal wrangle

Daimler has prevented a Chinese carmaker from unveiling a new minicar after the German carmaker claimed the model infringed on its design copyright for the Smart ForTwo.

The Noble, built by Shuanghuan Automobile, was due to feature at last week's Bologna auto show but the car was pulled after Daimler won a temporary order from an Italian court which banned Shuanghuan showing the new model.

Copycat: Daimler claims the Noble replicates the FourTwo
Copycat: Daimler claims the Noble replicates the FourTwo

A similar order was obtained by the company in Germany to prevent Shuanghuan's German distributor from showing the Noble at the Frankfurt Motor Show in September.

Bubble car

In a further legal twist, Martin Motors, the Chinese manufacturer's European distributor, has said it plans to sell the Noble as the Bubble in Europe, avoiding a potential legal dispute with UK sports carmaker Noble Automotive.

Should the Daimler dispute be resolved, Martin Motors will start selling the Bubble in Italy and Romania, with future plans of expanding into other European markets.

Martin Motors has said the Bubble would not be confused with the ForTwo, as the car is a four-seat, front-engined vehicle, while the Smart model is a two-seat car with a rear engine.

Legal challenge

The distributor claimed that Daimler took no legal action when the Bubble was shown at the Bucharest auto show in Romania.

The latest legal wrangle is not the first copyright issue that Smart has had to face.

In November 2006, the then DaimlerChrysler company threatened to sue Chinese firm Shandong HuoYun Electromobile if it continued production of an electric car which the German company said resembled the Smart ForTwo.

Email Small Delicious Icon  Delicious Small StumbleUpon Icon  Stumble Upon Small Facebook Icon Facebook Small Google Icon Google Bookmark
HAVE YOUR SAY
Click on the button to include your comments on this story